AccScience Publishing / BIJP / Volume 16 / Issue 2 / DOI: 10.29228/beytulhikme.89920
Cite this article
21
Views
Related Info Links
More by Authors Links
Journal Browser
Volume | Year
Issue
Search
News and Announcements
View All
RESEARCH ARTICLE

The Epistemological Function of Aristotelian Dialectic and Its Relationship to First Principles

Cemalettin Ergün1
Show Less
1 Department of Philosophy, Faculty of Letters, Istanbul University, Istanbul , Türkiye.
BIJP 2026, 16(2), 633–656; https://doi.org/10.29228/beytulhikme.89920
Received: 22 February 2026 | Accepted: 20 June 2026 |
© Invalid date by the Author. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution -Noncommercial 4.0 International License (CC-by the license) ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ )
Abstract

This article aims to analyze, from an epistemological perspective, Aristotle's claim in Topics I.2 that dialectic is "a way leading to the first principles." Although Aristotle defines the dialectical method as a type of syllogism that derives its premises from endoxa (generally accepted opinions), he simultaneously assigns this method the function of reaching the foundations of the philosophical sciences. This creates a problem concerning how an investigation proceeding from endoxa can provide an epistemic transition to the certain and indemonstrable first principles upon which demonstration (apodeixis) is based. The article addresses this problem in two stages. First, the position of the concepts of endoxa and phainomena (phenomena), which constitute the subject matter of dialectic, is evaluated within Aristotle's epistemology. It is demonstrated that the concept of phenomenon carries a dual meaning, showing that endoxa are not limited to common beliefs but include the experience-based judgments of tekhne holders as well. Second, the functioning of the dialectical practice used in Aristotle's works is analyzed, arguing that its examinational (eksetastike) structure enables the attainment of a science's definitional principle through a systematic process of diaporesis (examination of both sides of a puzzle). The article does not attribute meanings to dialectic such as "proving" or "discovering" principles. Rather, it concludes that dialectic functions as a method that establishes the necessity of these principles by organizing the internal debates of philosophical disciplines and the prevailing opinions on their subject matters within specific objectives.

Keywords
Dialectic
endoxa
phainomena
Aristotle
first principles.
References

1. Aristoteles, E. E., & Babür, S. (2015). Bilge Su Yayıncılık.

2. Aristotle. (1960). Topica (E. S. Forster, Ed.). Harvard University Press.

3. Aristotle. (2001). Aristotle’s Prior and Posterior Analytics (W. D. Ross, Ed.). Clarendon Press.

4. Aristotle. (2003). Commentary, Topics I & VIII (R. Smith, Ed.). Clarendon Press.

5. Aristotle. (2009). The Nicomachean Ethics (L. Brown, Ed.; D. Ross, Trans.). Oxford University Press.

6. Aristotle. (2015). Retorik (S. Babür, Trans.). BilgeSu Yayıncılık.

7. Aristotle. (2018). Ruh Üzerine (Ö. Aygün & G. Sev, Trans.). Pinhan Yayıncılık.

8. Aristotle. (1995b). The Complete Works of Aristotle (J. Barnes, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), Posterior Analytics (Vol. 1). Princeton University Press.

9. Aristotle. (1995a). The Complete Works of Aristotle (A. J. Jenkinson, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), Prior Analytics (Vol. 1). Princeton University Press.

10. Aristotle. (1995c). The Complete Works of Aristotle (W. A. Pickard-Cambridge, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), Topics (Vol. 1). Princeton University Press.

11. Aristotle. (1995d). The Complete Works of Aristotle (W. A. Pickard-Cambridge, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), Sophistical Refutations (Vol. 1). Princeton University Press.

12. Aristotle. (1995e). The Complete Works of Aristotle (J. L. Stocks, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), On the Heavens (Vol. 1). Princeton University Press.

13. Aristotle. (1995g). The Complete Works of Aristotle (D. Ross, Trans.). In J. Barnes (Ed.), Metaphysics (Vol. 2). Princeton University Press.

14. Aristotle, & Ross, W. D. (2001). Aristotle’s Prior and Posterior Analytics. Clarendon Press, for Sandpiper Books.

15. Baltussen, H. (2000). Theophrastus against the Presocratics and Plato: Peripatetic Dialectic in the De sensibus. Brill.

16. Barnes, J. (1980a). Aristotle and the Method of Ethics. Revue Internationale de Philosophie, 34(3).

17. Barnes, J. (1980b). Aristotle and the Method of Ethics. Revue Internationale de Philosophie, 34(3).

18. Bolton, R. (1991). Aristotle’s Method in Natural Science: Physics I. In E. L. Judson (Ed.), Aristotle’s Physics: A Collection of Essays. Clarendon Press.

19. Buck, C. D., & Petersen, W. (1944). A Reverse Index of Greek Nouns and Adjectives. University of Chicago Press.

20. Castalli, L. (2020). Introduction: Alexander, Aristotle’s Topics and Peripatetic Logic. In On Aristotle’s Topics 2: Alexander of Aphrodisias. Bloomsbury.

21. Cemallettin Ergün. (2024). İlkelere Giden Yol: Aristoteles ve Fârâbî’de Felsefi Diyalektik. İstanbul Üniversitesi Sosyal Bilimler Enstitüsü.

22. Evans, J. D. G. (2010). Aristotle’s Concept of Dialectic. Cambridge University Press.

23. Le Blond, J.-M. (1996). Logique et méthode chez Aristote. Librairie Philosophique Vrin.

24. McLeod, O. (1995). Aristotle’s Method. History of Philosophy Quarterly, 12(1).

25. Nussbaum, M. (2001). Saving Aristotle’s Appearances. In The Fragility of Goodness: Luck and Ethics in Greek Tragedy and Philosophy. Cambridge University Press.

26. Owen, G. E. L. (1961). Tithenai ta Phainomena. In Aristote et les problèmes de méthode. Publications Universitaires de Louvain.

27. Plato, & Taylor, C. C. W. (1991). Protagoras (Rev. ed.). Clarendon Press; Oxford University Press.

28. Reeve, C. D. C. (1995). Practices of Reason: Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics. Oxford University Press.

29. Smith, R. (1993). Aristotle on the Uses of Dialectic. In Synthese: Logic and Metaphysics in Aristotle and Early Modern Philosophy. Springer.

30. Striker, G. (2016). Aristotle’s Prior Analytics Book I: Translated with an Introduction and Commentary. Oxford University Press.

31. Thom, P. (2016). The Syllogism and Its Transformations. In E. C. D. Novaes & S. Read (Eds.), The Cambridge Companion to Medieval Logic. Cambridge University Press.

Share
Back to top
Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Electronic ISSN: 1303-8303 Published by AccScience Publishing