AccScience Publishing / BIJP / Volume 16 / Issue 2 / DOI: 10.29228/beytulhikme.90542
Cite this article
1
Download
9
Views
Related Info Links
More by Authors Links
Journal Browser
Volume | Year
Issue
Search
News and Announcements
View All
RESEARCH ARTICLE

Looking at the Ethics of Migration through Comparative Political Theory: Islam and Liberalism

İbrahim Buldur1
Show Less
1 Department of Political Science and Public Administration, Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, Sivas Cumhuriyet University, Sivas , Türkiye.
BIJP 2026, 16(2), 855–885; https://doi.org/10.29228/beytulhikme.90542
Received: 13 April 2026 | Accepted: 19 June 2026 |
© Invalid date by the Author. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution -Noncommercial 4.0 International License (CC-by the license) ( https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ )
Abstract

This article aims to comparatively analyze the views of contemporary liberal political theory and contemporary Islamic political thought on migration ethics based on comparative political theory. After a brief overview of the discipline of comparative political theory in the first section, the second and third sections examine the perspectives of contemporary Islamic political thought and contemporary liberal theory on open-border policy, migration ethics, and the rights of migrants/refugees, respectively, on the axis of their understanding of the human/individual. The fourth section identifies the commonalities and points of divergence between the two traditions' views on migration ethics. Islamic thought positions itself in favor of an open-border policy by arguing that migration plays a central role in life through the concept of hijra, that persecuted people must undertake hijra to live a dignified and just life, and that accepting refugees is a necessity through the concept of eman. The liberal tradition, on the other hand, approaches the ethics of migration through concepts such as freedom of contract, freedom of movement, and global equality of opportunity, justifying the open-border policy through the norms of individual freedom and universal moral equality. The article contends that both Islamic political thought and liberal political theory advance robust normative arguments in support of open-border policies and adopt a strongly critical position toward the imposition of border restrictions.

Keywords
Comparative political theory
ethics of migration
refugee
open bor der policy
Islam
liberalism.
References

1. Abd al-Rahim, M. (2008). Asylum: A moral and legal right in Islam. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 27(2), 15–23.

2. Agha, S. N. (2008). The ethics of asylum in early Muslim society. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 27(2), 30–40.

3. Akın, Ş. (2024). Phenomenological method: Its theoretical foundations and application. Karamanoğlu Mehmetbey Üniversitesi Sosyal ve Ekonomik Araştırmalar Dergisi, 26(47), 694–708.

4. Alexander, J. C. (2013). The centrality of the classics (Ü. Tatlıcan, Trans.). In A. Giddens & J. Turner (Eds.), Social Theory Today (1st ed., pp. 19–68). Say Yayınları.

5. Atak, Y. G., & Demir, A. F. (2020). Erdoğan’s and Merkel’s approaches to the Syrian refugee crisis: A comparative analysis in the context of the leaders’ priorities and practices. Avrasya Etüdleri, 57(1), 121–152.

6. Barnett, M. N. (1997). Bringing in the new world order: Liberalism, legitimacy, and the United Nations. World Politics, 49(4), 526–551.

7. Barzegar, A. (2019). The living fiqh, or practical theology, of Muslim humanitarianism. In R. Jureidini & S. F. Hassan (Eds.), Migration and Islamic Ethics: Issues of Residence, Naturalization and Citizenship (pp. 28–46). Brill.

8. Bauböck, R., Mourão Permoser, J., & Ruhs, M. (2022). The ethics of migration policy dilemmas. Migration Studies, 10(3), 427–441.

9. Baysa, H. (2017). The refugee system in light of the Islamic legal tradition of protection. İlahiyat Akademi Dergisi, 3(4), 37–48.

10. Bowen, J. R. (2004). Beyond migration: Islam as a transnational public space. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 30(5), 879–894.

11. Buchanan, A., & Moore, M. (2003). Introduction: The making and unmaking of boundaries. In A. Buchanan & M. Moore (Eds.), States, Nations and Borders: The Ethics of Making Boundaries (pp. 1–16). Cambridge University Press.

12. Burchill, S. (2009). Liberalism (A. Aslan, Trans.). In S. Burchill & A. Linklater (Eds.), Theories of International Relations (pp. 81–117). Küre Yayınları.

13. Carens, J. H. (1987). Aliens and citizens: The case for open borders. The Review of Politics, 49(2), 251–273.

14. Carens, J. H. (1992). Migration and morality: A liberal egalitarian perspective. In B. Barry & R. E. Goodin (Eds.), Free Movement (pp. 25–47). The Pennsylvania State University Press.

15. Carens, J. H. (2019). On the relationship between normative claims and empirical realities in immigration. In M. Hoesch & L. Laube (Eds.), Proceedings of the 2018 ZiF Workshop: Studying Migration Policies at the Interface Between Empirical Research and Normative Analysis (pp. 13–29). ULB Münster.

16. Cevizci, A. (2015). Philosophy of Knowledge (3rd ed.). Say Yayınları.

17. Dallmayr, F. (1997). Introduction: Toward a comparative political theory. The Review of Politics, 59(3), 421–427.

18. Dallmayr, F. (2004). Beyond monologue: For a comparative political theory. Perspectives on Politics, 2(2), 249–257.

19. Devran, Y., & Özcan, Ö. F. (2016). The Syrian issue through the language of discourse. Marmara İletişim Dergisi, 25, 35–52.

20. Duncombe, C., & Dunne, T. (2018). After liberal world order. International Affairs, 94(1), 25–42.

21. Elmadmad, K. (2008). Asylum in Islam and in modern refugee law. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 27(2), 51–63.

22. Erdoğan, M. (2017). Reconsidering liberalism: Its historical and philosophical foundations. In C. Uslu (Ed.), Handbook of Liberalism (2nd ed., pp. 63–99). Liberte Yayınları.

23. Euben, R. L. (1997). Comparative political theory: An Islamic fundamentalist critique of rationalism. The Journal of Politics, 59(1), 28–55.

24. Ez-Zühaylî, V. (1995). Aman (Safe-conduct). In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi. TDV İslâm Araştırmaları Merkezi. https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/eman#3-islam-hukuku

25. Fadl, K. A. E. (2003). The unbounded law of God and territorial boundaries. In A. Buchanan & M. Moore (Eds.), States, Nations and Borders: The Ethics of Making Boundaries (pp. 214–228). Cambridge University Press.

26. Fadl, K. A. E. (2020). Islamic ethics, human rights and migration. In R. Jureidini & S. F. Hassan (Eds.), Migration and Islamic Ethics (pp. 13–27). Brill.

27. Freeden, M., & Vincent, A. (2013). Introduction: The study of comparative political thought. In M. Freeden & A. Vincent (Eds.), Comparative Political Thought: Theorizing Practices (1st ed., pp. 1–23). Routledge.

28. Gibney, M. J. (1999). Liberal democratic states and responsibilities to refugees. The American Political Science Review, 93(1), 169–181.

29. Gibney, M. J. (2018). The ethics of refugees. Philosophy Compass, 13(10), e12521.

30. Hallaq, W. B. (2019). The Impossible State (Aziz Hikmet, Trans.; 1st ed.). Babil Kitap.

31. Hashmi, S. H. (2003). Political boundaries and moral communities: Islamic perspectives. In A. Buchanan & M. Moore (Eds.), States, Nations and Borders: The Ethics of Making Boundaries (pp. 181–213). Cambridge University Press.

32. Hassanzadeh, N. (2015). The canon and comparative political thought. Journal of International Political Theory, 11(2), 184–202.

33. Hayek, F. A. von. (2017). Liberalism (Ü. Çetin, Trans.). In C. Uslu (Ed.), Handbook of Liberalism (2nd ed., pp. 19–62). Liberte Yayınları.

34. Hidalgo, J. (2022). The libertarian case for open borders (İ. Hazır, Trans.). In J. Brennan, B. van der Vossen, & D. Schmidtz (Eds.), Handbook of Libertarianism (pp. 561–577). Episteme Yayınları.

35. Hosein, A. (2019). The Ethics of Migration: An Introduction (1st ed.). Routledge.

36. Ikenberry, G. J. (2011). The future of the liberal world order: Internationalism after America. Foreign Affairs, 90(3), 56–68.

37. Ikenberry, G. J. (2018). Why the liberal world order will survive. Ethics & International Affairs, 32(1), 17–29.

38. Iqtidar, H. (2024). Justice beyond rights: Haqq and Global South migration. American Political Science Review, 119(3), 1159–1172.

39. İnayet, H. (2008). Contemporary Islamic Political Thought (Y. Z. Cömert, Trans.; 1st ed.). Hece Yayınları.

40. Kibar, S. (2020). Open borders or closed borders: Is this the only question? Kilikya Felsefe Dergisi, 1, 62–76.

41. King, R., & Skeldon, R. (2010). ‘Mind the gap!’ Integrating approaches to internal and international migration. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 36(10), 1619–1646.

42. Köse, H. M. (2018). The foundations of Islamic political thought. In Islamic Political Thought: The Just State, the Virtuous City, and the Responsible Human Being (1st ed., pp. 27–50). İlem Kitaplığı.

43. Kukathas, C. (2005). Immigration. In H. LaFollette (Ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Practical Ethics (pp. 567–590). Oxford University Press.

44. Mack, E., & Gaus, G. F. (2017). Classical liberalism and libertarianism: The tradition of liberty (A. Akçiçek & B. Şahin, Trans.). In C. Uslu (Ed.), Handbook of Liberalism (2nd ed., pp. 141–185). Liberte Yayınları.

45. March, A. F. (2009). What is comparative political theory? The Review of Politics, 71(4), 531–565.

46. Masud, M. K. M. (1990). The obligation to migrate: The doctrine of hijra in Islamic law. In D. F. Eickelman & J. Piscatori (Eds.), Muslim Travellers: Pilgrimage, Migration, and the Religious Imagination (1st ed., pp. 28–49). Routledge.

47. Miller, D. (2016). Strangers in Our Midst. Harvard University Press.

48. Mohammed, H., & Jureidini, R. (2022). Umma and the nation-state: Dilemmas in refugee ethics. Journal of International Humanitarian Action, 7(1), 1–25.

49. Munir, M. (2011). Refugee law in Islam. Journal of Social Sciences, 4(2), 1–18.

50. Naqvi, T. H. (2013). Islam and migration. In I. Ness (Ed.), The Encyclopedia of Global Human Migration. John Wiley & Sons.

51. Noll, G. (2000). Universalism versus particularism. In Negotiating Asylum (pp. 73–96). Brill.

52. Nur Manuty, M. (2008). The protection of refugees in Islam: Pluralism and inclusivity. Refugee Survey Quarterly, 27(2), 24–29.

53. Nyang, S. (2001). Religion and the maintenance of boundaries. In D. Miller & S. H. Hashmi (Eds.), Boundaries and Justice (Vol. 4, pp. 203–212). Princeton University Press.

54. Osman, F. (2003). Islam and human rights: A challenge to Muslims and the contemporary world. In A. el-Efendi (Ed.), Rethinking Islam and Modernity (1st ed., pp. 59–105). Pınar Yayınları.

55. Önkal, A. (1998). Hijra. In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi. TDV İslâm Araştırmaları Merkezi. https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/hicret#1

56. Özel, A. (1998). Hijra. In TDV İslâm Ansiklopedisi. TDV İslâm Araştırmaları Merkezi. https://islamansiklopedisi.org.tr/hicret#2-fikih

57. Puchala, D. J. (2005). World hegemony and the United Nations. International Studies Review, 7(4), 571–584.

58. Reed, H. E., Ludwig, B., & Braslow, L. (2016). Forced migration. In M. J. White (Ed.), International Handbook of Migration and Population Distribution (pp. 605–625). Springer.

59. Shacknove, A. E. (1985). Who is a refugee? Ethics, 95(2), 274–284.

60. Siddiqui, A. (1997). Ethics in Islam: Key concepts and contemporary challenges. Journal of Moral Education, 26(4), 423–431.

61. Singer, P., & Singer, R. (2010). The ethics of refugee policy. In J. S. Fishkin & R. E. Goodin (Eds.), Population and Political Theory (pp. 285–304). Wiley-Blackwell.

62. Steiner, H. (1992). Libertarianism and the transnational migration of people. In B. Barry & R. E. Goodin (Eds.), Free Movement (pp. 87–94). The Pennsylvania State University Press.

63. Sunar, L., & Kavak, Ö. (2018). Introduction. In L. Sunar & Ö. Kavak (Eds.), Islamic Political Thought: The Just State, the Virtuous City, and the Responsible Human Being (1st ed., pp. 1–24). İlem Kitaplığı.

64. Vacano, D. von. (2015). The scope of comparative political theory. In Annual Review of Political Science (Vol. 18, pp. 465–480). Annual Reviews.

65. Vincent, A. (2006). Modern Political Ideologies (A. Tüfekçi, Trans.; 1st ed.). Paradigma Yayıncılık.

66. Walzer, M. (1983). Spheres of Justice: A Defence of Pluralism and Equality. Basic Books.

67. West, D. (2020). An Introduction to Continental Philosophy (A. Cevizci, Trans.; 5th ed.). Paradigma Yayınları.

68. Yılmaz, A. (2009). Applied ethics as an opportunity offered by philosophy. Muhafazakar Düşünce Dergisi, 5(19–20), 67–78.

69. Yılmaz, F. (2022). Comparative political theory. In M. A. Ağcan (Ed.), Contemporary Political Theory (1st ed., pp. 411–445). İstanbul Bilgi Üniversitesi Yayınları.

70. Yusuf, H. (2022). Ethics in action for sustainable development. In J. D. Sachs, O. Flanagan, M. S. Sorondo, W. Vendley, A. Annett, & J. Thorson (Eds.), Ethics in Action for Sustainable Development (pp. 235–237). Columbia University Press.

71. Zia-Ul-Haq, M., & Ifraq, T. (2020). Contemporary Islamic legal discourse on the notion of territoriality. Islamic Studies, 59(2), 171–202.

Share
Back to top
Beytulhikme An International Journal of Philosophy, Electronic ISSN: 1303-8303 Published by AccScience Publishing